Try running the premium and check your plugs after 500 miles for detonation. If you are detonation than go back to pure gas. Sunoco is 10% ethanol, others are 0%. It has to be on the pump by law (Fed. law i believe).
Ethanol has more octane and less btu/gallon. The btu is the energy content thus you will put out lower hp per lb. of fuel. Partially offset by increased tuning parameters.
Avalon