BJL630....I don't think you are altogether wrong as your AV needs are different than mine.? My desire to have a 6 speed is to have better power and torque on the road particularly when towing.? You don't necessarily need more cubic inches to do that if you have more and better ratio gears.? By comparison, an 18-wheeler would need 2,000 CI to tow 80,000 GVW if it were not for a bunch of forward gears and electrica rear gear.? ?Current 4-speed solution is minimal in my case.? First, with a lower 1st....getting rolling from a dead stop will be much better.? I've said it before and I'll say it again.? The AV is a DOG off the line with a 5.3 and 3.73.? It's my 2nd AV with that set up and towing with the present 4-speed is minmal.? Always down shifting to the radically different gears, high RPMs before shifting up, etc.? Having a better spread in the intermediate gears will help the upshift on entering freeway ramps with or without towing and the downshift in city traffic.? Right now, I inevitably have to put my foot down to get adequate acceleration to blend in with freeway traffic speeds.? I just have to push harder while towing.? I live in DFW where getting into traffic is an issue.? That may not be your case.? Finally, I think 2 ODs is better than one.? The lower for towing so you don't lug the engine and tranny in the high OD yet avoid turning 3000 RPMs at 65-70 MPH in 3rd as in the current 4-speed tranny.? ?With the 6 speed (high OD), you can still run all day at 70-80 towing at lower RPMs.? And....probably better MPGs.
My general assessment is the present 4-speed is just-ok for daily driving.....but not for towing.? By comparative analysis.....can you imagine an 18 wheeler with just? 6-8 gears?? They would never get rolling.? And notice....current tranny design trends these days are moving to more forward gears.... Eg: Caddy, Denalli, Tundra, etc.? Must be a reason and I'm all for it.
BTW...I grew up with the "PG Hydro" (Chevy's 2-speed automatic) on the opposite end of this example.....you don't want to go there....more gears is mo' better!