YES. I knew it wasn't just me. The only wasy I know it is closed is when the wind noise goes away. Since we here in Minnesota are still dealing with crappy weather, I ran mine through the touchless car wash. All seemed fine until I got under the dryer. It blew all kinds of water into the truck and down my back! When I close the window, it always goes into the opposite mode (from moon to sun or vice-versa). Never feels like there is a middle, closed position.